Blog

The Victorian Is Closing on Main Street: What Changes at Heritage Square, and What Stays Open to Everyone

On a Sunday morning at 2640 Main Street, about 28 farmers, 14 food vendors and 5 Main Street merchants set up on the parking lot. Education booths and musicians fill the driveway and the lawn between The Victorian and the museum next door. A city staff report estimates that about 70% of the market's weekly visitors stay for one to two hours. It also says that of Santa Monica's four weekly farmers markets, the Sunday one is widely regarded as the most family-friendly, largely because of that lawn.

That Sunday scene is the part of Heritage Square most protected by what comes next. On October 5, The Victorian announced it would close after 20 years. But the City Council had already approved the lease transfer to a members club back on March 24, and the terms for the market, the lawn and the parking were negotiated then. The open questions are narrower: when the lawn will be open, and how Sundays will work during construction.

The last weekends of The Vic

The Victorian made the announcement on Instagram that Monday afternoon. "After 20 incredible years, The Victorian is closing its doors," the post read, "but not before we say thank you." Its annual Halloween party will be its final weekend. When the Santa Monica Daily Press reported the closing, that left four more weekends. The article did not give a date for the party.

The house had two lives. By day it was a restaurant and a wedding and event venue. At night it became a nightclub on three levels, with DJs and live music in the basement, on the main floor and upstairs on weekend nights. It was also known for its long-running "Salsa Thursday." The announcement gave no reason for the closing and said nothing about the building's future. The property is owned by the City of Santa Monica.

City ownership is why the next chapter is already public record.

What the city approved in March

The day after the announcement, the Daily Press reported on city records showing a plan to turn the property into a members club. On March 24, 2026, the City Council voted 7-0 to transfer the lease for 2640 Main St. to a new company, The Santamonican Club, LLC. The item passed on the consent calendar and nobody pulled it for discussion.

The city staff report notes that the Victorian is nearly 123 years old and that many of its building systems are near the end of their useful life. The operator proposes to pay for the renovation itself, with no public subsidy or rent credits, over an estimated 12 to 18 months. The planned work includes:

  • Roof replacement and new mechanical and HVAC systems
  • New siding, paint and façade improvements
  • A commercial kitchen renovation, a re-imagined all-day coffee bistro, and a full-service restaurant and bar
  • A spa and wellness center, a new pool, a family and youth facility, and a fitness center with TechnoGym equipment
  • Landscaping that preserves mature trees and adds new ones
  • Full perimeter fencing and security, including new windows and doors

The amended lease runs 10 years, with three five-year options to extend. A concept site plan in the report shows a "Family Park" and "Family Gardens" behind the two historic houses. The report doesn't say whether those spaces would be open to the public or only to members.

The Sunday commitments, in writing

Before the lease was negotiated, the Council asked for five community benefits: support for the Sunday Farmers Market, continued public access to the museum lawn, community events, a local scholarship membership program and a local hiring program. The farmers market is the most concrete of these. Under the current arrangement, The Victorian opens its restrooms to farmers and shoppers during market hours and lets the market store items on site. The amended lease carries that forward:

"the Operator commits to continue providing the City with support, access, and use of the Victorian's restrooms, storage, power / electricity, and water facilities to support the Sunday Farmer's Market on Main Street."

Here is how the public parts of Heritage Square line up against the new terms:

Public use today What the amended lease says Not yet stated in the records
25 on-site public parking spaces Stay available for public use How parking works during construction
Museum lawn for picnics and market music Public access "will not be reduced from existing conditions" Hours of the "designated access periods"
Restrooms, storage, power and water for the Sunday market Operator keeps providing them How Sundays run during 12 to 18 months of work
Community programming with the California Heritage Museum Operator gives in-kind food, beverage and marketing support; the museum leads Specific event dates

Where the lease is less specific

The lawn language is firm about quantity and open about timing. The lease says public access will stay consistent with the Heritage Museum lease requirements. It also says the lawn will remain visible and accessible from the street and "available for public use during designated access periods." The section on the lawn doesn't say what those periods are.

The way people reach the lawn would also change. Visitors now cross the active driveway. The operator proposes a main pedestrian entrance straight from the Main Street sidewalk. The report says that would avoid conflicts with cars and keep the lawn separate from the club's operating areas. It also says the site has had operational problems in the past when the line between driveway and lawn wasn't clearly drawn. Put that next to the full perimeter fencing on the renovation list, and the lawn starts to look like a defined public space with its own gate from the street. Today it's an open edge of a nightclub property.

The lease also calls for free community gatherings. For the club's first year, the report names three:

  1. A winter event open to the wider Santa Monica community, which could use the lawn and the surrounding stretch of Main Street.
  2. A spring event coordinated with the Main Street Business Improvement Association and neighborhood groups such as the Ocean Park Association.
  3. A fall gathering celebrating neighborhood businesses and community organizations.

The operator also has to give the city an annual report on the community benefits it provided, including events, attendance and partnerships.

A timeline written into the rent

No opening date has been announced, and the records don't say what a membership would cost. The rent schedule does sketch a timeline, though. After a one-time $10,000 concession, the operator pays $10,000 a month until a new certificate of occupancy is issued or 18 months pass, whichever comes first. Rent then rises to $20,000 a month, with 3% annual increases starting in year five and a city review at that point. That 18-month cap matches the top of the estimated construction window, so the lease is written around reopening within about a year and a half. The 18-month cap sets when the rent goes up. It isn't a promised opening date.

Some residents will join without paying dues. The lease reserves up to 20% of total membership capacity for free scholarship memberships for qualifying Santa Monica residents. These are per household and come with full clubhouse access. A scholarship attachment describes a limited number of annual memberships for residents who contribute to the community. It gives examples such as educators, small-business owners, nonprofit leaders, artists, entrepreneurs and working parents, and it says some club events will be open to the public.

The council approved the agreement as exempt from CEQA review under the categorical exemption for existing facilities. The records reviewed for this post don't say whether the exterior changes, the pool or the landscaping will go before the Landmarks Commission.

Heritage Square and Main Street this fall

For now, nothing about Sundays has changed. The Main Street Farmers Market runs Sundays from 8:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m., year-round, rain or shine. It closes only for certain holidays or extreme conditions, and the city describes it as having about 40 certified California farms plus entertainment and Main Street retail vendors.

Next door at 2612 Main Street, the California Heritage Museum is showing "Some Assemblage Required" by Lou D'Elia through November 15, 2026. The museum's homepage lists hours of Wednesday through Sunday, 11 a.m. to 3:30 p.m., and says its free adjacent parking is available every day except Sunday. That's the day the market sets up on the lot.

Two nearby dates fall within The Victorian's last month:

  • October 18: The Main Street Block Party, featuring Day of the Dog, closes Main Street between Pier Avenue and Pacific Street from 5 a.m. to 10 p.m., according to the city's street closures page.
  • October 31 to November 1: The Santa Monica Pier holds its free Día de los Muertos celebration in the Merry-Go-Round building, with community ofrendas and performances.

After the Halloween party, the next public milestones at 2640 Main will be a construction start, a new certificate of occupancy, and the club's first winter community event on the lawn.

If you own a home near Main Street and want to talk through how a change at Heritage Square might fit into your own plans, The Samulon Group is glad to help. We follow city records like this one closely and will give you a measured read on what they mean for your block. Contact Us.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With Us

The Samulon Group is a leading real estate group in Los Angeles and Orange County and has helped hundreds of buyers find their dream home.
Contact Us