On a Saturday morning in mid-August, about two dozen volunteers came to San Vicente Boulevard near Gretna Green with shovels, wheelbarrows and bags of mulch. They spent hours packing mulch around the coral trees, hoping it would hold moisture in soil that had dried as hard as concrete. The Brentwood Homeowners Association brought coffee, donuts and direction.
Six weeks later, on Saturday, September 26, more volunteers came back with UCLA students and spread fresh mulch on the median near Montana Avenue. That same day, the first Brentwood Bash took over the eastbound side of San Vicente between Montana and Barrington.
These trees have about as much legal protection as anything in Brentwood. An ordinance says the median is to be preserved "in perpetuity." Yet this summer they stayed alive mostly because neighbors paid for water and did the work by hand.
The trouble came from a broken part. A failed "backflow valve" cut off water to the entire irrigation system buried under the median. The system had been off for months before anyone caught it. Nobody noticed until the trees started to show the stress.
"All the trees, all at once, started looking very unhealthy," said Nancy Freedman, who has advocated for the median for years through her nonprofit, the Coral Tree Endowment Fund. Once the water stopped, the soil hardened so much that it no longer took in moisture easily, even after repairs began. Freedman also warned that "suffering trees can take on pathogens that can kill a tree."
Her group acted without waiting for the city. The Endowment Fund hired a water truck to drive the length of San Vicente and water the trees directly. It also brought in an outside arborist, TreeCareLA, to assess every coral tree on the strip. Landscaper Tracey Price, whose crew has been running the water trucks, says the city's repairs should eventually get water to the roots without soaking the surface, where the trees are most vulnerable.
Here is where things stood by late September:
The reporting so far names no funding source or timeline for that full replacement.
The trees went into the median after the Pacific Electric Red Car line was removed around 1942. In 1976 the city made them Historic-Cultural Monument No. 148. A second protection, the San Vicente Scenic Corridor Specific Plan, has been in effect since 1980. In a September 30 piece, Brentwood News laid out how the two differ.
| Historic-Cultural Monument No. 148 | San Vicente Scenic Corridor Specific Plan | |
|---|---|---|
| In place since | 1976 | 1980 |
| What it names | The trees, listed "Between 26th & Bringham" | The coral trees and the median strip itself |
| Replacement | City Planning says the designation "does not legally require exact replacement" | Section 7A requires replacing a lost tree with a coral tree of at least 24-inch box size |
| Changes to the median | Not addressed in the official listing | Section 7B bars any "major alteration" without a hearing before the Board of Public Works |
You can read the monument entry in the city's Historic-Cultural Monuments list. According to Brentwood News, nobody has been able to find the original 1976 nomination paperwork, which might define the monument more broadly. City Planning's Office of Historic Resources would be the place to ask.
Officials read these rules differently. Emily Loughran, a Brentwood activist, says the Specific Plan defines "coral tree" as Erythrina caffra, so a lost tree cannot be replaced with "any old tree." Pete Brown, a spokesperson for Councilwoman Traci Park, said neither protection "expressly prohibits the planting of another species of tree as long as another species of tree is not being planted in lieu of the coral trees." Last November, StreetsLA took the strictest view, saying the historic designation allows coral trees only. That is why the $1.2 million greening project includes no new trees.
Brentwood News put questions to nine city agencies. One answer was clear: Colin Sweeney, a spokesperson for the Los Angeles Department of Transportation, said LADOT has no plans to turn any part of the median into a traffic or bus lane.
The tree guardians disagree on one practical point. Freedman worries that watering the grass around the trees could oversaturate their roots. Loughran says the grass helps by keeping the soil around it soft and moist.
The question has real stakes because of the trees' biology. Coral tree wood is spongy. In heavy winter rain it can soak up so much water that branches, or whole trees, come down under the weight. Too little water can kill a coral tree, and so can too much. Broken pipes have flooded parts of the median before.
The grass is also central to the city's greening project, which proposes swapping it for drought-tolerant plants. Whether that swap counts as a "major alteration" is still undecided. If it does, Section 7B requires a public hearing first. So the argument about watering the grass ties directly to the median's legal future. Brentwood News says it will cover the greening plan in the third part of its series and practical next steps in the fourth. Neither part had been published as of September 30.
The trees have critics too. Coral trees come from South Africa, and some residents believe the species is a poor fit for the local climate. Carolyn LoBuglio, chair of the Brentwood Community Council, said no tree is perfect for this climate. She added that any replacement, whether oak, sycamore or another species, would take decades to grow the canopy the coral trees already provide.
"The coral trees are the very symbol of Brentwood." — Carolyn LoBuglio, Brentwood Community Council
The list of people involved is mostly neighbors. The September 26 workday was organized by Loughran and the Brentwood Homeowners Association. Freedman and Price were there, along with a staff member from Councilwoman Park's office. Volunteers known as the Coral Tree Crew worked on the soil around the mature roots. Earlier, Brentwood News photographed Loughran with Amir Ebtehadj, Park's new Brentwood field representative.
Park's office says its role is to coordinate among the city departments. "The San Vicente median is part of Brentwood's history and identity, and we want to make sure decisions about its future are thoughtful, sustainable, and informed by the people who live here," Park said. She added that her office is working with the Brentwood Community Council and other neighborhood groups.
Longtime activist Teri Kahn sees the city's mixed messages as the main obstacle. She said the city has blocked new irrigation lines over concerns about old plumbing, and that "one year we are allowed to plant trees and the next they deny permission because there are electrical lines 6 feet under the median." Ray Klein, the Brentwood Homeowners Association's representative to the Community Council, said no one remembers the city ever reversing a monument designation. He noted that the City Council could, in theory, amend both the designation and the Specific Plan.
The San Vicente Coral Trees community site lists several ways to help, and none of them takes much time:
The site's call for historic recognition of "the complete corridor" suggests organizers believe the 1976 listing doesn't yet cover everything they want protected. That fits Brentwood News' reporting that the monument names the trees, not the median.
Marta Samulon brings more than three decades of real estate experience on the Westside, and the San Vicente coral trees are one of Brentwood's best-known landmarks. If you're thinking about the trees on your own property, how your garden and irrigation hold up, or how landscaping shapes what your home is worth, The Samulon Group is happy to talk it through. Contact Us.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.